Background: Among rate-control or rhythm-control strategies, there is conflicting evidence as to which is the best management approach for non-valvular atrial fibrillation (AF) in elderly patients. Design: We performed an ancillary analysis from the ‘Registro Politerapie SIMI’ study, enrolling elderly inpatients from internal medicine and geriatric wards. Methods: We considered patients enrolled from 2008 to 2014 with an AF diagnosis at admission, treated with a rate-control-only or rhythm-control-only strategy. Results: Among 1114 patients, 241 (21.6%) were managed with observation only and 122 (11%) were managed with both the rate- and rhythm-control approaches. Of the remaining 751 patients, 626 (83.4%) were managed with a rate-control-only strategy and 125 (16.6%) were managed with a rhythm-control-only strategy. Rate-control-managed patients were older (p = 0.002), had a higher Short Blessed Test (SBT; p = 0.022) and a lower Barthel Index (p = 0.047). Polypharmacy (p = 0.001), heart failure (p = 0.005) and diabetes (p = 0.016) were more prevalent among these patients. Median CHA2DS2-VASc score was higher among rate-control-managed patients (p = 0.001). SBT [odds ratio (OR) 0.97, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.94–1.00, p = 0.037], diabetes (OR 0.48, 95% CI 0.26–0.87, p = 0.016) and polypharmacy (OR 0.58, 95% CI 0.34–0.99, p = 0.045) were negatively associated with a rhythm-control strategy. At follow-up, no difference was found between rate- and rhythm-control strategies for cardiovascular (CV) and all-cause deaths (6.1 vs. 5.6%, p = 0.89; and 15.9 vs. 14.1%, p = 0.70, respectively). Conclusion: A rate-control strategy is the most widely used among elderly AF patients with multiple comorbidities and polypharmacy. No differences were evident in CV death and all-cause death at follow-up.
Choice and Outcomes of Rate Control versus Rhythm Control in Elderly Patients with Atrial Fibrillation: A Report from the REPOSI Study / Paciullo, Francesco; Proietti, Marco; Bianconi, Vanessa; Nobili, Alessandro; Pirro, Matteo; Mannucci, Pier Mannuccio; Lip, Gregory Y. H.; Lupattelli, Graziana; Tettamanti, Mauro; Pasina, Luca; Franchi, Carlotta; Perticone, Francesco; Salerno, Francesco; Corrao, Salvatore; Marengoni, Alessandra; Licata, Giuseppe; Violi, Francesco; Corazza, Gino Roberto; Marcucci, Maura; Eldin, Tarek Kamal; Di Blanca, Maria Pia Donatella; Lanzo, Giovanna; Astuto, Sarah; Ardoino, Ilaria; Cortesi, Laura; Prisco, Domenico; Silvestri, Elena; Cenci, Caterina; Emmi, Giacomo; Biolo, Gianni; Guarnieri, Gianfranco; Zanetti, Michela; Fernandes, Giovanni; Chiuch, Massimiliano; Vanoli, Massimo; Grignani, Giulia; Casella, Gianluca; Pulixi, Edoardo Alessandro; Bernardi, Mauro; Bassi, Silvia Li; Santi, Luca; Zaccherini, Giacomo; Mannarino, Elmo; Nuti, Ranuccio; Valenti, Roberto; Ruvio, Martina; Cappelli, Silvia; Palazzuoli, Alberto; Salvatore, Teresa; Sasso, Ferdinando Carlo; Girelli, Domenico; Olivieri, Oliviero; Matteazzi, Thomas; Barbagallo, Mario; Plances, Lidia; Alcamo, Roberta; Calvo, Luigi; Valenti, Maria; Zoli, Marco; Arnò, Raffaella; Pasini, Franco Laghi; Capecchi, Pier Leopoldo; Bicchi, Maurizio; Palasciano, Giuseppe; Modeo, Maria Ester; Peragine, Maria; Pappagallo, Fabrizio; Pugliese, Stefania; Di Gennaro, Carla; Postiglione, Alfredo; Barbella, Maria Rosaria; De Stefano, Francesco; Cappellini, Maria Domenica; Fabio, Giovanna; Seghezzi, Sonia; De Amicis, Margherita Migone; Mancarella, Marta; Mari, Daniela; Rossi, Paolo Dionigi; Damanti, Sarah; Ottolini, Barbara Brignolo; Bonini, Giulia; Miceli, Emanuela; Lenti, Marco Vincenzo; Padula, Donatella; Murialdo, Giovanni; Marra, Alessio; Cattaneo, Federico; Secchi, Maria Beatrice; Ghelfi, Davide; Anastasio, Luigi; Sofia, Lucia; Carbone, Maria; Davì, Giovanni; Guagnano, Maria Teresa; Sestili, Simona; Mancuso, Gerardo; Calipari, Daniela; Bartone, Mosè; Meroni, Maria Rachele; Perin, Paolo Cavallo; Lorenzati, Bartolomeo; Gruden, Gabriella; Bruno, Graziella; Amione, Cristina; Fornengo, Paolo; Tassara, Rodolfo; Melis, Deborah; Rebella, Lara; Delitala, Giuseppe; Pretti, Vincenzo; Masala, Maristella Salvatora; Pes, Chiara; Bolondi, Luigi; Rasciti, Leonardo; Serio, Ilaria; Fanelli, Filippo Rossi; Amoroso, Antonio; Molfino, Alessio; Petrillo, Enrico; Zuccalà, Giuseppe; Franceschi, Francesco; De Marco, Guido; Chiara, Cordischi; Marta, Sabbatini; D’Aurizio, Gabriella; Romanelli, Giuseppe; Amolini, Claudia; Chiesa, Deborah; Picardi, Antonio; Gentilucci, Umberto Vespasiani; Gallo, Paolo; Annoni, Giorgio; Corsi, Maurizio; Zazzetta, Sara; Bellelli, Giuseppe; Szabo, Hajnalka; Arturi, Franco; Succurro, Elena; Rubino, Mariangela; Sesti, Giorgio; Loria, Paola; Becchi, Maria Angela; Martucci, Gianfranco; Fantuzzi, Alessandra; Maurantonio, Mauro; Serra, Maria Grazia; Bleve, Maria Antonietta; Gasbarrone, Laura; Sajeva, Maria Rosaria; Brucato, Antonio; Ghidoni, Silvia; Di Corato, Paola; Agnelli, Giancarlo; Marchesini, Emanuela; Fabris, Fabrizio; Carlon, Michela; Turatto, Francesca; Baritusso, Aldo; Amabile, Annalisa; Omenetto, Elisabetta; Scarinzi, Paolo; Manfredini, Roberto; Molino, Christian; Pala, Marco; Fabbian, Fabio; Boari, Benedetta; De Giorgi, Alfredo; Paolisso, Giuseppe; Rizzo, Maria Rosaria; Laieta, Maria Teresa; Rini, Giovanbattista; Mansueto, Pasquale; Pepe, Ilenia; Borghi, Claudio; Strocchi, Enrico; De Sando, Valeria; Pareo, Ilaria; Sabbà, Carlo; Vella, Francesco Saverio; Suppressa, Patrizia; Valerio, Raffaella; Agosti, Pasquale; Fontana, Flavia; Loparco, Francesca; Capobianco, Caterina; Fenoglio, Luigi; Bracco, Christian; Giraudo, Alessia Valentina; Testa, Elisa; Serraino, Cristina; Fargion, Silvia; Bonara, Paola; Periti, Giulia; Porzio, Marianna; Tiraboschi, Slivia; Peyvandi, Flora; Tedeschi, Alberto; Rossio, Raffaella; Ferrari, Barbara; Monzani, Valter; Savojardo, Valeria; Folli, Christian; Magnini, Maria; Conca, Alessio; Gobbo, Giulia; Pallini, Giada; Balduini, Carlo L.; Bertolino, Giampiera; Provini, Stella; Quaglia, Federica; Dallegri, Franco; Ottonello, Luciano; Liberale, Luca; Chin, Wu Sheng; Carassale, Laura; Caporotundo, Silvia; Traisci, Giancarlo; De Feudis, Lucrezia; Di Carlo, Silvia; Liberato, Nicola Lucio; Buratti, Alberto; Tognin, Tiziana; Bianchi, Giovanni Battista; Giaquinto, Sabrina; Purrello, Francesco; Di Pino, Antonino; Piro, Salvatore; Rozzini, Renzo; Falanga, Lina; Spazzini, Elena; Montrucchio, Giuseppe; Greco, Elisabetta; Tizzani, Pietro; Petitti, Paolo; Perciccante, Antonio; Coralli, Alessia; Salmi, Raffaella; Gaudenzi, Piergiorgio; Gamberini, Susanna; Semplicini, Andrea; Gottardo, Lucia; Vendemiale, Gianluigi; Serviddio, Gaetano; Forlano, Roberta; Masala, Cesare; Mammarella, Antonio; Raparelli, Valeria; Basili, Stefania; Perri, Ludovica; Landolfi, Raffaele; Montalto, Massimo; Mirijello, Antonio; Vallone, Carla; Bellusci, Martino; Setti, Donatella; Pedrazzoli, Filippo; Guasti, Luigina; Castiglioni, Luana; Maresca, Andrea; Squizzato, Alessandro; Molaro, Marta; Bertolotti, Marco; Mussi, Chiara; Libbra, Maria Vittoria; Miceli, Andrea; Pellegrini, Elisa; Carulli, Lucia; Veltri, Francesca; Sciacqua, Angela; Quero, Michele; Bagnato, Chiara; Colangelo, Lidia; Falbo, Tania; De Giorgio, Roberto; Serra, Mauro; Grasso, Valentina; Ruggeri, Eugenio; Ilaria, Benzoni; Salvi, Andrea; Leonardi, Roberto; Grassini, Chiara; Mascherona, Ilenia; Minelli, Giorgio; Maltese, Francesca; Damiani, Giampaolo; Capeci, William; Mattioli, Massimo; Martino, Giuseppe Pio; Biondi, Lorenzo; Ormas, Monica; Pettinari, Pietro; Romiti, Roberto; Messina, Silvia; Cavallaro, Federica; Ghio, Riccardi; Favorini, Serena; Col, Anna Dal; Minisola, Salvatore; Afeltra, Antonella; Alemanno, Pamela; Marigliano, Benedetta; Pipita, Maria Elena; Castellino, Pietro; Blanco, Julien; Zanoli, Luca; Cattaneo, Marco; Fracasso, Paola; Amoruso, Maria Valentina; Saracco, Valter; Fogliati, Marisa; Bussolino, Carlo; Durante, Vittorio; Eusebi, Giovanna; Tirotta, Daniela; Mete, Francesca; Gino, Miriam; Cittadini, Antonio; Vigorito, Carlo; Arcopinto, Michele; Salzano, Andrea; Bobbio, Emanuele; Marra, Alberto Maria; Sirico, Domenico; Moreo, Guido; Scopelliti, Francesco; Gasparini, Francesca; Cocca, Melissa; Ballestrero, Alberto; Ferrando, Fabio; Berra, Sergio; Dassi, Simonetta; Nava, Maria Cristina; Graziella, Bruno; Baldassarre, Stefano; Fragapani, Salvatore; Galanti, Giorgio; Mascherini, Gabriele; Petri, Cristian; Stefani, Laura; Girino, Margherita; Piccinelli, Valeria; Nasso, Francesco; Gioffrè, Vincenza; Pasquale, Maria; Scattolin, Giuseppe; Martinelli, Sergio; Turrin, Mauro; Sechi, Leonardo; Catena, Cristina; Colussi, Gianluca; Nieves, Ramirez Duque; Alberto, Muela Molinero; Pedro, Abad Requejo; Vanessa, Lopez Pelaez; Lara, Tamargo; Xavier, Corbella Viros; Francesc, Formiga; Jesus, Diez Manglano; Esperanza, Bejarano Tello; Esther, Del Corral Behamonte; Maria, Sevil Puras; Romero, Manuel; Blanca, Pinilla Llorente; Cristina, Lopez Gonzalez-Cobos; Victoria, Villalba Garcia M.; Saez, Lopez; Bosco, Juan; Susana, Sanz Baena; Marta, Arroyo Gallego; Concepcion, Gonzalez Becerra; Antonio, Fernandez Moyano; Hernandez, Mercedes Gomez; Borrego, Manuel Poyato; Raquel, Pacheco Cuadros; Florencia, Perez Rojas; Beatriz, Garcia Olid; Sara, Carrascosa Garcia; Alfonso, Gonzalez-Cruz Cervellera; Marta, Peinado Martinez; Garcia, Sara Carrascosa; Alberto, Ruiz Cantero; Antonio, Albarracín Arraigosa; Montserrat, Godoy Guerrero; Ángel, Barón Ramos Miguel; Manuel, Machin Jose; Ignacio, Novo Veleiro; Lucía, Alvela Suarez; Alfonso, Lopez; David, Rubal Bran; Iria, Iñiguez Vazquez; Monica, Rios Prego. - In: DRUGS & AGING. - ISSN 1170-229X. - 35:4(2018), pp. 365-373. [10.1007/s40266-018-0532-8]
Choice and Outcomes of Rate Control versus Rhythm Control in Elderly Patients with Atrial Fibrillation: A Report from the REPOSI Study
Paciullo, Francesco;Damanti, Sarah;
2018-01-01
Abstract
Background: Among rate-control or rhythm-control strategies, there is conflicting evidence as to which is the best management approach for non-valvular atrial fibrillation (AF) in elderly patients. Design: We performed an ancillary analysis from the ‘Registro Politerapie SIMI’ study, enrolling elderly inpatients from internal medicine and geriatric wards. Methods: We considered patients enrolled from 2008 to 2014 with an AF diagnosis at admission, treated with a rate-control-only or rhythm-control-only strategy. Results: Among 1114 patients, 241 (21.6%) were managed with observation only and 122 (11%) were managed with both the rate- and rhythm-control approaches. Of the remaining 751 patients, 626 (83.4%) were managed with a rate-control-only strategy and 125 (16.6%) were managed with a rhythm-control-only strategy. Rate-control-managed patients were older (p = 0.002), had a higher Short Blessed Test (SBT; p = 0.022) and a lower Barthel Index (p = 0.047). Polypharmacy (p = 0.001), heart failure (p = 0.005) and diabetes (p = 0.016) were more prevalent among these patients. Median CHA2DS2-VASc score was higher among rate-control-managed patients (p = 0.001). SBT [odds ratio (OR) 0.97, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.94–1.00, p = 0.037], diabetes (OR 0.48, 95% CI 0.26–0.87, p = 0.016) and polypharmacy (OR 0.58, 95% CI 0.34–0.99, p = 0.045) were negatively associated with a rhythm-control strategy. At follow-up, no difference was found between rate- and rhythm-control strategies for cardiovascular (CV) and all-cause deaths (6.1 vs. 5.6%, p = 0.89; and 15.9 vs. 14.1%, p = 0.70, respectively). Conclusion: A rate-control strategy is the most widely used among elderly AF patients with multiple comorbidities and polypharmacy. No differences were evident in CV death and all-cause death at follow-up.I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
